When it comes to healthcare in the U.S., being insured doesn’t always mean being protected. Many patients walk into hospitals expecting basic care — and walk out with medical bills that feel shocking, unfair, and downright absurd. Unfortunately, most of these billing practices are entirely legal.
From secret fees to outrageous markups, millions of Americans are blindsided by medical costs they never saw coming — and never agreed to. Even with laws like the No Surprises Act in place, loopholes still allow providers and insurers to pass the financial burden onto patients.
Here are 10 medical billing practices that should be illegal — but aren’t — and what you can do to avoid falling into these traps.
1. Out-of-Network ER Doctors at In-Network Hospitals
Imagine heading to your local, in-network emergency room — only to find a separate surprise bill arriving days later from an out-of-network provider who treated you. In that same hospital.
This happens because hospitals often contract independently with ER doctors, anesthesiologists, and radiologists — many of whom don’t accept your insurance. And since you rarely get a say in who treats you, you’re stuck with the bill — even in emergencies.
Though federal protections now limit some of these charges, gray areas still allow this billing in non-emergency situations or for services like ambulances.
2. “Facility Fees” for a Basic Doctor Visit
Think you’re just paying for the doctor’s time? Think again.
If your physician’s office is affiliated with a hospital system, even if it’s miles away, you may be charged a hidden “facility fee” of $150 to $300 or more for a simple office visit.
This legal workaround allows hospitals to tack on extra charges — simply because the location is part of their network. These fees are often buried deep in the bill and vary widely with little regulation.
3. Double Billing for a Single Procedure
Hospitals can unbundle one treatment into multiple line items: a tray fee, a recovery fee, a prep charge — all tied to a single procedure. This legal “itemization” strategy inflates costs, making it hard for patients to understand what they’re actually being charged for.
Unless you actively request an itemized bill and dispute ambiguous charges, you could be paying twice — or more — for the same.
4. Charges From Doctors You Never Saw
So-called “ghost charges” happen when a specialist or consulting physician bills you for reviewing your file but never spoke to or examined you.
Hospitals claim these professionals provided medical value, but the charges can easily add up to hundreds or even thousands of dollars. It’s legal, unless contested, and most patients don’t even notice unless they scrutinize every line item carefully.
5. Ambulance Rides That Cost More Than a Car
Ambulance billing remains one of the costliest and least regulated areas of healthcare. In many cities and suburban areas, ambulances are operated by private, out-of-network companies, meaning your insurance may not cover much — or any — of the cost.
Many patients report balance bills above $2,000 after emergency transport, even though they never had a choice in using the service.
6. Hospital Markups on Basic Medication
Ever see $12 for a single Tylenol on your hospital bill? Or $100+ for a basic IV? Welcome to hospital pharmacy pricing, where markup rates can range from 500% to 10,000%.
These charges are chalked up to overhead and staffing, but critics say it’s a profit-padding practice that remains widely unchecked.
7. “Observation” Status That Derails Coverage
Staying overnight in a hospital doesn’t always mean you’re an inpatient. If you’re placed under “observation,” your insurance might not cover your medications, room, or follow-up treatment, even though care looks identical.
This billing trick protects hospitals legally while dumping hefty bills back on the patient, often without them knowing the difference.
8. Charged for Procedures That Were Canceled
Cancelling a surgery or scheduled test doesn’t always cancel the cost. Facilities often bill for pre-op prep, room setup, and even paperwork — even if no procedure occurs.
Without vigilance, you could pay thousands for something that never actually happened. And getting refunds often requires navigating disputes.
9. Surprise Bills for Preventive Care You Thought Was Free
Under current federal law, preventive services like vaccines, screenings, and yearly checkups should come with no out-of-pocket costs.
But if a provider codes your visit as “diagnostic” instead of preventive, your free checkup turns into a billable appointment — often without your knowledge.
10. Balance Billing: After Insurance Pays, You Still Owe More
Even after insurance pays their share, providers can bill you for the remainder — sometimes unexpectedly. This is known as balance billing and, unless banned in specific cases, it’s entirely legal.
This practice is common with out-of-network labs, imaging centers, and specialists whose services you never explicitly agreed to. Many patients don’t discover this until a collections notice arrives.
🛡️ Protect Yourself from Predatory Medical Bills
The most frustrating part of unexpected medical billing is how confusing and unclear the entire process can be. Patients put trust in doctors and insurance providers — only to discover fine print filled with technicalities.
Here’s what you can do:
-
Always request an itemized bill after any medical visit.
-
Ask up front if all providers are in-network—especially for planned procedures.
-
Appeal questionable charges and escalate when needed—many hospitals quietly remove charges if pressed.
-
Use hospital billing advocates or patient navigators through nonprofit health foundations.
Final Thoughts
While several reforms have tackled surprise billing, there are still far too many legal traps in the U.S. healthcare billing system. Until tighter laws close these gaps, informed patients remain the first line of defense.
Learning to question, verify, and examine every bill isn’t just good advice — it could save you thousands of dollars.